Fix problems with running payroll

1. Your PAYE bill isn't what you expected

Every month you have to pay HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) what you owe as part of running payroll for your employees.

There are things you should check if your PAYE bill isn’t what you expected when you view your online account.

What to check

Make sure you sent your Full Payment Submission (FPS) or Employer Payment Summary (EPS) in time for the account to update.

You should also check that you:

Employees starting and leaving

Check that you correctly reported any employees starting or leaving.

You may get an incorrect bill and duplicate payroll records if you made a mistake. Both are usually corrected automatically - contact HMRC if your PAYE bill is still wrong by the 12th of the next tax month.

Correcting errors

If you find a mistake, follow the guidance to:

You can also correct mistakes if you paid your employee the wrong amount or made incorrect deductions.

Get help to correct your PAYE bill

Contact HMRC’s employer helpline if you need help.

2. You made a mistake in your FPS or EPS

Your PAYE bill might be wrong if you made a mistake in your FPS or EPS. You might have to correct:

  • pay or deductions
  • payment dates
  • start or leaving dates for your employee
  • employee information
  • reports sent in advance
  • National Insurance category letters
  • amounts in your Employer Payment Summary (EPS)
  • the Apprenticeship Levy you owe (starting from April 2017) if you, or employers you’re connected to, have an annual pay bill of more than £3 million

You’ll only be charged a penalty for a mistake if you didn’t take reasonable care or did it deliberately.

If you’ve reported the wrong pay or deductions

To correct a mistake made in the current tax year, update the year-to-date figures in your next regular Full Payment Submission (FPS).

For previous tax years, send an Earlier Year Update (EYU) showing the difference between what you originally reported and the correct figure. If your payroll software can’t send an EYU, you can use HMRC’s Basic PAYE Tools.

You can only use an EYU for tax years when you were reporting online in real time.

The rules are different if you find a mistake in your final FPS of the year.

Correct a pension death benefit or flexibility payment

If you’re a pension administrator who needs to correct a flexibility payment or death benefit payment, you must:

  • select the ‘pension flexibility payment’ or ‘pension death benefit payment’ indicator
  • update the ‘pensions drawdown taxable payment’ or ’pensions drawdown non-taxable payment’ fields (or both) with the difference between what you originally reported and the correct figures

If your employee has stopped working for you

Include them in your next FPS and correct their year-to-date figures. Include their original ‘Date of leaving’ and put the same or a later ‘Payment date’ than the one shown on their final FPS.

Correct the payment date in your FPS

You should use the date you paid your employees in your FPS.

Send an additional FPS with the correct payment date if you’ve sent one with the wrong payment date. Write ‘H - correction to earlier submission’ in the ‘Late reporting reason’ field.

Send your corrected FPS by the 19th of the tax month after you sent your original FPS. HMRC will apply the correction to the right month.

If the wrong date was in different tax month, you must realign your payroll to the correct tax period.

Correct an employee’s start or leaving date

Update your payroll records with the correct date if you put the wrong start or leaving date for an employee in your FPS.

Don’t report the amendment in your next FPS as this may create a duplicate record for the employee.

Correct your employee’s personal information

Correct your next FPS if you’ve made a mistake with your employee’s personal details.

Don’t report updates to more than one of your employee’s personal details (for example their name, date of birth or gender) in the same FPS. Your payroll records may be duplicated if you do, and your PAYE bill might be wrong.

If your employee’s details (for example their address or surname) change:

Correct FPS reports sent in advance

If you’ve sent FPS reports in advance that need to be corrected (for example because an employee leaves), you should:

  • send another FPS for the tax month the correction relates to, making sure you fill in all relevant fields and revising the year-to-date figures if needed

  • correct any other FPS reports you sent in advance that are affected by the change

Correct an employee’s National Insurance category letter

How you do this depends on why the category letter changed, and in which tax year.

You’ve used the wrong category letter in the current tax year

Report the mistake in your next FPS.

  1. Add the category letter you’ve used incorrectly.

  2. Put ‘0’ in all National Insurance fields for this category letter except ‘Employee’s NICs this payment’, and enter the amount you have repaid or recovered here, for example put -£300 if you’re repaying an employee’s overpayment of £300.

  3. Add the correct category letter, and enter the correct year-to-date National Insurance for this category letter.

  4. Put ‘0’ in all National Insurance fields for the incorrect category letter for the rest of the tax year - you don’t need to do this if the category should never have been used.

Some software allows you to correct this by adjusting net pay. You’ll still need to keep a record of the change.

Your employee’s category letter changed during the tax year

In your next FPS:

  1. Continue to report year-to-date information for the old category.

  2. Put ‘0’ in all ‘In this pay period’ fields for this category, and use the ‘Employee’s NICs this payment’ field to adjust any underpayment or overpayment of National Insurance.

  3. Add the correct category letter, and enter the correct year-to-date National Insurance for this category letter.

If the mistake was in a previous tax year

Send an EYU with:

  • negative amounts in all the National Insurance year-to-date fields in the incorrect category letter, to reduce the employee’s National Insurance to zero

  • the correct category letter and correct year-to-date National Insurance

If the mistake caused an overpayment or underpayment

You must correct your employee’s National Insurance deductions if they paid too little or too much because they were on the wrong category letter.

Correct an EPS

To correct a mistake in the current tax year, send an EPS with the correct year-to-date figures.

For previous tax years, send an EPS with the correct year-to-date figures for the tax year where you made the mistake.

3. You paid HMRC the wrong amount

What you need to do to correct a payment depends on whether you paid too much or too little, and how the error occurred.

If you’ve paid HMRC too little

If you underpaid because of a mistake in your Full Payment Submission (FPS) or Employer Payment Summary (EPS), correct it in your next regular report. HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) will add the underpayment to your next PAYE bill.

If you underpaid because you entered the wrong amount when paying HMRC, pay the balance as soon as possible or you may have to pay interest or a penalty. Use your Accounts Office reference when paying.

If you’ve paid HMRC too much

If you overpaid because of a mistake in your FPS or EPS, make the correction in your next regular report. HMRC will take the overpayment off your next PAYE bill.

If you overpaid because you entered the wrong amount when paying HMRC, or you made a duplicate payment, you can balance your account by paying less in your next PAYE bill.

You can also claim a refund if you’ve overpaid by contacting HMRC’s employer helpline.

HMRC will repay directly into your account if you’ve sent an EPS with your bank details.

Write to HMRC with your bank details if you can’t include them with your EPS.

Reclaim an overpayment for a previous tax year

You must work out why you overpaid before you can reclaim an overpayment for a previous tax year.

Work out why you overpaid

Compare what you’ve paid HMRC with what you’ve owed in your tax account. You may have overpaid if your payments didn’t take into account:

  • an overpayment carried over from a previous tax year
  • Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) or statutory pay for parents that you were entitled to reclaim
  • any repayments made to employees, for example because you used the wrong tax code
  • any corrections to your reports
  • student loan deductions
  • employees who left, for example because you didn’t report them correctly to HMRC
  • any incentive payments from HMRC to send reports online
  • any Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) deductions, or if you made deductions incorrectly

You also may have overpaid if you paid HMRC:

  • for the wrong tax year
  • more than once for the same bill
  • an estimated amount in advance

For duplicated or estimated payments, tell HMRC what you paid, what you should have paid and why you paid the additional amount.

Making your claim

Once you know why you’ve overpaid, you can claim your repayment from HMRC. You’ll need to tell them:

  • your business’s name and address
  • your PAYE reference - this is in your employer registration letter from HMRC
  • your contact telephone number
  • how much you’ve overpaid - for each tax year you’re claiming
  • the tax month you overpaid in (if possible)
  • why you overpaid - for each tax year you’re claiming
  • whether you’ve claimed this overpayment before

HMRC will offset the amount against your PAYE bill in the current tax year. If you don’t owe anything, they will offset the amount:

  • against a PAYE bill from a previous tax year
  • against other taxes you owe, for example Corporation Tax

You’ll only get a refund if you don’t owe HMRC any tax.

You must apply by letter if your company has been dissolved or struck off.

4. You paid your employee the wrong amount or made incorrect deductions

You can correct a mistake with an employee’s pay or deductions by updating the year-to-date figures in your next regular Full Payment Submission (FPS).

You can also correct it by sending an additional FPS before your next regular FPS is due. You need to:

  • update the ‘this pay period’ figures with the difference between what you originally reported and the correct figures
  • correct the year-to-date figures
  • put the same payment date as the original FPS
  • put the same pay frequency as the original FPS
  • put ‘H - Correction to earlier submission’ in the ‘Late reporting reason’ field

Correct a pension death benefit or flexibility payment

If you’re a pension administrator who needs to correct a flexibility payment or death benefit payment, you must:

  • select the ‘pension flexibility payment’ or ‘pension death benefit payment’ indicator
  • update the ‘pensions drawdown taxable payment’ or ’pensions drawdown non-taxable payment’ fields (or both) with the difference between what you originally reported and the correct figures

If you underpaid your employee

Pay your employee the amount you underpaid them. On or before the day of this payment, send an additional FPS with:

  • the difference between what you originally reported and the correct amount in the ‘In this pay period’ field
  • updated year-to-date figures
  • ‘H - Correction to earlier submission’ in the ‘Late reporting reason’ field

Correct an employee’s National Insurance deductions

What you need to do depends on when you made the mistake.

If the mistake was in this tax year

Repay or deduct the balance from your employee. Update the year-to-date figures to the corrected amount in your next regular FPS or send an additional FPS.

If you deducted too little, you can’t recover more than the employee’s National Insurance contribution due that month.

Example

You deducted £100 too little in January. In February, your software calculates an £80 National Insurance deduction, which means you can recover up to £80 towards the underpayment that month (a £160 deduction in total).

Recover the remaining £20 in another month.

Pay any underpayment to HMRC straight away.

If the mistake was in a previous tax year

Send an Earlier Year Update (EYU) with the difference between:

  • the amount of National Insurance you originally deducted
  • the correct amount you should have deducted

If you deducted or reported too much National Insurance, you also need to set the ‘NIC refund indicator’ to ‘Yes’ or ‘No’.

Put ‘Yes’ if you either:

  • deducted the right amount of National Insurance from your employee, but reported it to HMRC incorrectly - do this even though no refund was due
  • refunded your employee after you deducted too much National Insurance from their pay

Put ‘No’ only if you owe your employee a refund that you haven’t paid, for example because they’ve left your employment.

If you deducted too little National Insurance, pay HMRC the underpayment straight away. You can then recover the amount from your employee by making deductions from their pay.

You can’t recover more than the amount of National Insurance the employee owes in a month (so the employee pays no more than double their normal contribution). Carry over the difference to later months - you can only make deductions in the tax year when you made the mistake and the year after.

Correct an employee’s student loan repayments

What you need to do depends on when you made the mistake.

If the mistake was in this tax year

Repay or deduct the balance from your employee. Update the year-to-date figures to the corrected amount in your next regular FPS or send an additional FPS.

If you deducted too little, you can’t recover more than the student loan repayment due that month.

Example You deducted £50 too little in June. In July, your software calculates a £30 student loan deduction, which means you can recover up to £30 towards the underpayment that month (a £60 deduction in total).

Recover the remaining £20 in another month.

If the mistake was in a previous tax year

If you deducted too little, you don’t need to do anything. Your employee can contact the Student Loans Company to find out how it affects them.

If you deducted too much, repay your employee and:

  • if you noticed the mistake on or before 19 April, send an FPS with the corrected ‘Student loan repayment year to date’ figure as of 5 April for the previous tax year
  • if you noticed the mistake after 19 April, send an Earlier Year Update (EYU) with the difference between what you originally deducted and the correct amount