Route Risks

Average: 4.6 (9 votes)

Developed by: 
David Taylor
App charge: 
Free

Route Risks analyses the safety of roads by using road safety data published by the UK Department for Transport.

To use the application, enter a start and end address for a route of your choice. You can filter collisions included in the results by selecting different severity levels and years using the checkboxes.

The following statistics are calculated to help assess how dangerous the route is:

  • Total number of collisions.
  • Number of collisions per kilometre
  • Weighted number of collisions per kilometre. This is calculated by assigning a weighted value to each collision on the route using its severity. Fatal collisions are assigned a weight of 3, serious collisions are assigned a weight of 2, and slight collisions have a weight of 1.
  • Total number of casualties.
  • Number of casualties per kilometre.

The route is displayed on an interactive map, and a heatmap is used to highlight collision hotspots. Sections of the route with the highest relative density of collisions will appear red. The heatmap also takes into account the severity of collisions, with fatal/serious collisions affecting the results more than slight collisions.

Uses dataset: 
Apps submitted to data.gov.uk are currently approved for publication on the general level of their context and appropriateness. Whilst we review these on a periodical basis, we do not own responsibility for the regular update and maintenance of these apps. Any queries about individual apps or tools published need to be directed to the originator.

Comments

RouteRisks app

The app calculates, for any route (sequence of links) the total number of casualties / collisions that have occurred in recent years.  But this is done without any regard to the flows on those links.  To measure the risk for any driver traversing that route (the chance that he/she will be involved in an accident whilst traversing that route), you would need to divide the observed number of accidents on each link by the estimated average flow on that link, and sum these values over all the links in the route.

To take a simple example: suppose there were two alternative parallel routes to choose from.  The first has had 12 accidents in recent years whilst the second has had only 10.  The app, as specified, would choose the second route as being the safer. However, if the first route has ten times the flow of the second, the risk to any single driver is far less on the first than the second.  

Trying the measure risk without any knowledge of exposure (flows) is likely to lead to virtually meaningless conclusions.

 Flag as offensive