Speed limit dataset

Status: 
Escalated to data holder
Data request description: 
We need a downloadable list of all speed-limit signs, with designated speed and location (grid reference) and facing direction. All the information must be known by local councils or other government bodies - it is they who erect and maintain the signs, so data.gov.uk should just collect it all together and make it available - the information is part of the law, so it cannot be secret or commercial in any way. Any format is fine. Then we can have our satnav or smartphone 'bleep' if we inadvertantly exceed the limit.
Reason: 
Other
I have not found any link to it
Suggested use: 
Business Use
Personal Use
Then we can have our satnav or smartphone 'bleep' if we inadvertantly exceed the limit.
Benefits overview: 
And all the law-abiding drivers will start concentrating on the traffic, rather than on trying to remember what number was on the last speed-limit sign they passed, which might even prevent some accidents.

Comments

Speed limits data

There's a previous Data.gov.uk discussion on this.

Basically the problem is that there is no public authority responsible for maintaining speed limit information as a national dataset. The Highways Agency is responsible for speed limits on motorways and trunk roads. Speed limits on other roads are set by the relevant Local Traffic Authority, i.e. councils.

So while it would certainly be useful to have this information available, it's not simply a case of unlocking an existing dataset for re-use as open data.

-- Owen Boswarva, 13/04/2013

 Flag as offensive 

Use of ODUG budget

Like Owen says this is a case where the data is spread across ~100 different organisations and no comprehensive open dataset exists.

But....

Making an 'Open' set of routable road geometries with definitive speed limits would be a fantastic use of ODUG/ODI budget. The raw information exists in open format and as statutory data *has* to be freely available for inspection. The only reason it isn't available widely as open processed data, is there is no commercial incentive for someone to go the trouble of collating it all, attaching it to street/road geometries and then publishing it back as open data or an open WMS. Crowd-sourcing really would be an immense waste of everyones time, and if the data gets embedded in Sat Nav or self-driving cars etc the legal situation could get complicated...

The data has been collected by Nokia (Navteq) and TomTom (TeleAtlas) who act as data gatekeeprs and license the data on under commercial terms.

Are ODUG able to use their budget in this way?

I'm thinking ODUG could do something through the same channels as used to maintain the road works portal (same people responsible), and use VMD 2013 for the base street geometries.

 Flag as offensive 

Funding

Blair,

Based on their terms of reference my understanding is the ODUG does not really have a budget as such. The Data Strategy Board has a budget to "buy back" existing datasets from public authorities, and the ODUG's remit is simply to advise on how that money should best be spent. (In practice of course that's not an approach that fits all datasets, and the ODUG seems to also be doing quite a bit of useful lobbying and troubleshooting to unlock additional data.)

The ODI is outside the DSB/ODUG process and does have its own budget, but seems geared mainly towards funding of start-ups. I suppose they might be willing to provide seed capital if someone came up with a business plan based on production of a speed limit dataset, but it's difficult to see how such a proposition could be sustainably monetised if that speed limit dataset was then released as open data.

(Personally I would oppose any use of DSB/ODUG or ODI budget for this if the result resembled the ELGIN road works portal, because of course that isn't open data.)

This idea might be suitable for funding through the Technology Strategy Board. The TSB accepts applications for Innovation Vouchers, and open data is one of the areas they have been interested in. I think it would be worthwhile to use TSB money to fund production of datasets directly where there is a demonstrable gap in our open information infrastructure. However Innovation Vouchers are only for small amounts.

There is a broader issue here: should the Government be funding production of "missing" open data requirements like this? I think there's a strong argument for public funding to fill gaps in the reference data infrastructure, and there are plenty of start-ups and SMEs who would be willing and able to do the work. However this is rather outside the scope of the ODUG data request process.

-- Owen Boswarva, 14/04/2013

 Flag as offensive 

reply...

> Like Owen says this is a case where the data is spread across ~100 different organisations

OK, so, at least to start with, data.gov.uk should provide a page with 100 links, one to eachlocal authority's dataset. Plenty of people using data.gov.uk are capable of writing code tothen combine it all.

> definitive speed limits

Yes, it needs to be a definitive list with a sound legal basis.

> attaching it to street/road geometries and then publishing it back as open

I think this, while useful, is something different. data.gov.uk should just provide the raw data,it is up to the users of the data to do the combining with other datasets.

> Crowd-sourcing really would be an immense waste of everyones time

Not 'would', but 'is' - look at e.g. 'wikispeedia' (in wikipedia). I want my satnav/smartphone to know the official government-supplied speed limit."I'm sorry, Mr. policeman, I was traveling 58mph because some unknown contributorto an unofficial database typoed 60" is hopeless.

Crowd-sourcing is great for some things, but not for a 'substitute' for a legal dataset.

 Flag as offensive 

Organisation and investment

Data.gov.uk only provides links and metadata for datasets submitted by data publishers. In this context that means each council would have to productise their speed limits data in a re-usable format, put it in an accessible location online, and then submit the details to Data.gov.uk.

That would require a substantial amount of organisation and investment. (This is the common barrier to open data release of national datasets that derive from local government sources. We have the same issues with Public Rights of Ways data and roadworks information, for example.)

-- Owen Boswarva, 14/04/2013

 Flag as offensive