National Health Data, what would be useful

I'm co-ordinating data feeds from national health organisations into the data.gov.uk site. If you have any ideas, issues or questions relating to health data please post them here.

Comments

Why are you replicting what

Why are you replicting what the NHS Information Centre already do????

 Flag as offensive 

Not replicating, doing...

Check out his profile he works for the NHS Information Centre.

 Flag as offensive 

A breakdown of costs by PCT or Trust

On individual trusts, total costs and then that broken down into cost areas, so staff, equipment, services etc. My main target is IT costs, not national projects, just day to day equipment and supplies, and recorded IT maintenance support man-hours. All this data which when compared and contrasted, in many different ways, may prove or disprove, either adequate IT staffing levels and highlight lack of IT awareness/training by all staff and where savings can be made, or identified. An example would be, if GP staff knowledge of printers, printer maintenance is inadequate and this then leads to a higher cost in terms of IT man-hours spent clearing printers, then even though the cost is kept down the level of IT support may not be at the best it can be. IE providing a better level of service, repairing a GP's computer which is not working rather than clearing a printer which you may be able to argue that the users, (GPs included) of such equipment should know the basics of maintaining such equipment.

 Flag as offensive 

Questions and wish-lists

I'm still not clear whether this site is supposed to offer value-added above existing data releases, or function merely as a 'hub'. If the latter, then it will be useful to the lay-user to be able to locate data from DH, NHS IC, NCHOD, HPA etc. in one place provided (and this is the crunch) that links are direct to the data in question and are durable.

The former is a more ambitious goal, but having the HPA epidemiology data and Dr. Foster Hospital Guide results in an analytically tractable format (i.e. .csv or .xls) would be my opening wish-list; the Dr. Foster stuff, in particular, seems deliberately opaque in its current form.

Finally, will you be including data from the public health observatories? Having this collated in one place would be very useful, as they have some good datasets, but it's currently rather difficult to ascertain 'who's got what'.

Thank-you

 Flag as offensive 

Questions and wish-lists

The site will provide both, a hub to existing public sources and links to new data. Maintaining the links is of course a concern with an increasing number of contributing organisations and source data growing exponentially, we'll need users of this service to help keep it live and durable.

In terms of content, the intention is to expand coverage but unlike other Government areas the NHS is not a single entity but comprised of a large and diverse range of corporate entities most of which are not Crown so not covered by Crown Copyright licence provisions. We also have to pay special attention to patient confidentiality and statutory controls on access to and use of health data.

Not with standing these challenges, we do want to make access to health data as straightforward as possible and your ideas and suggestions are much appreciated.

 Flag as offensive 

coding and costing for paediatric operations

There is a paucity of coding information and even less information about true costs to the NHS and trusts for paediatric orthopaedic operations available on current systems.  This needs to be improved urgently.

 Flag as offensive 

Suggest you see NHS IC

http://www.ic.nhs.uk/

Is this one of the "efficiencies" the government could save money on, not duplicating effort?

 Flag as offensive 

seconded

couldn't have put it better myself. *sigh*

 Flag as offensive 

Completely agree with you.

Completely agree with you.

 Flag as offensive 

I'm not sure if this is

I'm not sure if this is exactly the kind of response you were looking for, but I think it would be very helpful in terms of medical research if NHS comorbidity data was available. This would of course be anonymised, but to know whether diagnosis of one condition in an individual shows any correlation or trend towards another diagnosis at a later date - or indeed whether it might anti-correlate, would provide huge clues to where one might look for causative factors.

 Flag as offensive 

Patients linked to expenses

I am often tasked with considering the financial efficiency of healthcare. While there is plenty of data on patient treatment, there is very little clarity on expenses. Both sets of data are also kept so remote that drawing conclusions as to what the net costs of given procedures are is almost impossible.

I would very much appreciate it if such data could be linked in some way (or, at least, made available for matching periods and segmentation).

For instance, outpatient, vs elective vs A&E expenses would be a useful data series to have.

Thanks,

Gavin

 Flag as offensive 

Financial efficiency

Hi Gavin

We may have what you are looking for. CamIsis (www.camisis.co.uk) provides a financial reporting and benchmarking tool, bringing together data from a wide variety of sources.

My apologies, but we are not on these blogs and forum sites yet. If you would like to see our system, just get in touch and I can arrange a free-trial.

Best regards

Scott

 Flag as offensive 

Costs for procedures

If you're looking for the costs for individual procedures, it may also be worth looking at the Reference Costs data, published by the Department of Health.

http://data.gov.uk/dataset/nhs-reference-costs-2009-10

 Flag as offensive 

Patients linked to expenses

Turukawa
A belated response. I assume you mean the cost of these services.

There are no national collections of local service line cost data. It is possible to derive comparable price information using NHS national service line tariff price (PBR @ HRG) multiplied by the volume of activity by hospital by period. Similar data is produced nationally for use by NHS organisations.

You may also like to review the PBR data recently released via data.gov.uk.

 Flag as offensive 

How to publish free NHS mobile app?

We are a Finnish IT company developing B2B abd B2C mobile applications working on almost every mobile (not only on iPhone than on ordinary cheap mobiles too). With our omaNHS app the user can easily search and retrieve NHS service providers, (the name, address, phone number, call directly to that number, web address, location on the map). The search can be done by name or part of it or by category or part of it). If the service provider has email address the user can contact that address without having any email capability on his/her mobile.

Yes I know that we can send our app here but are there any other channels to use.

This app we going to give free (the app is vertical mobile app) as SaaS to show and promote what can be done with ordinary mobile. Our motto is that there should be more KISS-style mobile apps to assist people in their daily living.

 Flag as offensive 

protection health map data

I would be grateful if you can support me with any references that help me to examine how web services can provide relevant health information about the population.

 Flag as offensive 

Clarification please

Dear poster
There are signicant resources available from ONS, the NHS IC and UK Statistics hub on UK population and or geographic health statistics. We are working to surface more of these through data.gov.uk.

In the meantime If you can provide a little more detail we may be able to point you to the most appropriate published resource.

 Flag as offensive 

The former is a much a lot

The former is a much a lot more ambitious goal, but having the HPA epidemiology information and Dr. Foster Hospital Guide outcomes in an analytically tractable format (i.e. .csv or .xls) would be my opening wish-list; the Dr. Foster stuff, in specific, appears deliberately opaque in its current form.
Finally, will you be including information from your public wellness observatories? Acquiring this collated in 1 location would be truly useful, as they have some good datasets, but it is currently rather difficult to ascertain 'who's got what'

 Flag as offensive 

Patients with chronic illnesses

Over the past eight years, I encountered many GP's and Specialists with an attitude towards patients, including myself, of them being the all knowing, when in truth they know little or nothing of the condition from which you are suffering. I was taken ill in Cape Town in 2002. I came home, against the advice of the Doctor treating me there, thinking I would be better at home under the NHS. Hindsight is a wonderful thing. How totally wrong I was. Over the past eight years my health has become progressively worse. Even though I have had Private Tests twice, and the results came back positive - Lyme Disease, the NHS tests were negative, as are so many other sufferers. My MP did try to raise the issue in a debate in the HOUSE OF COMMONS, a question was asked by Hugo Swire - he was thanked by the then Minister of State for Health - Ann Keen - she thanked the Right Honourable Gentleman for bringing this relatively new disease to their attention. Ignorance is bliss. On the One Show the Doctor who appears frequently said if you get bitten by a tick, you need to see your GP and get treatment immediately, otherwise the disease can develope into something more serious. Indeed it does. The former Rugby League Captain, Mike Gregory was bitten, and died three years later. Many become wheelchair bound, they suffer loss of vision, and their nervous system is afftected. This is what is happening to me. I saw a GP a few weeks ago - Out of Hours Clinic. His best friend is in a wheelchair. He said he knows how hard it is for me, but I must keep on beating the drum. Where to I go, and to whom do I speak??

There are so many other sufferers here in the UK, the Government is failing us. Will David Cameron take on board what is happening to people all over the country. We do all travel. Walk over hill and dale. Where does one ever see a warning about the dangers of ticks in humans? Not in your GP surgery, but there are huge posters in our vets waiting rooms. Speaks volumes.

I do not smoke, drink or take drugs, if I did there this everything out to to help me under the NHS.

Something sadly is very wrong.

Patient - North East Derbyshire

 Flag as offensive 

Hi, I have posted a request

Hi, I have posted a request under "request data" for a better data feed of gp data (and other health facilitys). If that could be implemented, it would be great.

 Flag as offensive 

NHS

I'd like the following:

1. NHS price list (for each individual service, along with any codes)

2. Referrals by GP for any of the above services.

Regards,

Zafar

 Flag as offensive 

Registers and Clinical Databases

Hi Dean

The Department of Health and the Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership (HQIP) both agree there's a pressing need for a single catalogue of all disease and procedure registers, case registers and clinical databases, covering both conditions and procedures for England and Wales.

There's hundreds dispersed across the country but no way of accessing them which means these rich datasets are lost to us with implications for epidemiological research, needs assessment and quality improvement.

Identifying and making these registers and clinical databases more visible is certainly in line with the Information Revolution. If they can be identified HQIP are committed to develop the results into a database and make it available as a free and fully searchable online resource. The catalogue would link the local data (essentially step 5 in Tim Berners-Lee’s five stages of publishing public data). This catalogue can then be used by clinicians, researchers, commissioners, patients and others to locate the most suitable clinical databases and registers for their needs.

I'd be interested in hearing any suggestions and am available to discuss it [hassan.choudhury@hqip.org.uk]

Regards

Hassan Choudhury

Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership (HQIP)

E: hassan.choudhury@hqip.org.uk

W: www.hqip.org.uk/

 Flag as offensive 

NHS GP practice spend data

Keep up the great work! It would be fantastic if you could provide GP practice spend data for each actual product bought: name of product, supplier, cost. Do you have this type of data, or know where it can be sourced?

Thanks

Michael

 Flag as offensive 

Let check again in...

I think you can find out what you need in ONS, the NHS IC and UK Statistics hub on UK population. I heard they update something about your problem.

 Flag as offensive 

Quality of NHS data

Having spent 4 years trying to find out how to improve the qulity of NHS data - and being told that the data I want to analyse will have its first data set that may be of sufficient quality in 2014 - then I would love to know how other people have managed to get the NHS to double enter, check, validate and verify data collected at all levels.

 Flag as offensive 

data quality

I spent a lot of tie just trying to get decent quality information in a sensible format for dentist and gp locations: without which a lot of further analysis will fall down. A very frustrating experience and nobody seems to want to put it right. If the very simple building blocks like this aren't reliable, then everything else is unlikely to be robust. Happy to go into details if anyone does have the clout to get things fixed!

 Flag as offensive 

Data quality taken for granted

Good point!  In principle, a dataset could be fit for some uses, but not others, for example it could support regional analysis but not LA level.  And there is an argument that forcing the data to be out there is the best way of improving its quality.  But there does sometimes seem to be a lot of assuming data quality is OK about these days.  Poor data can generate poor models, poor comparisons and poor cherry picking.

 Flag as offensive 

NHS costs

It would be very interesting to have a look at some data on NHS costs, since healtth care is free in the Uk. This way people who immigrate here will have at least an idea about how well they are treated here as compared to other countries or locations...

 Flag as offensive 

99escorts - How exactly would

99escorts - How exactly would data on NHS costs assist potential immigrants?  Illogical, captain!

 Flag as offensive