CCG Maps

Status: 
Closed
Outcome: 
Not a data request or a data issue
Data request description: 
Boundaries of the clinical care groups. This isn't exactly a request to release it, as it's available on their website http://www.england.nhs.uk/resources/ccg-maps/ - but I think it would be useful if they were also catalogued on data.gov.uk
Suggested use: 
Other
I'm curious as to why the boundaries appear 'over precise' in estuaries & coastal areas.
Benefits overview: 
Suggestion is to make it more discoverable; it's already available.

Comments

CCG maps

Hi Peter,

It's not a great idea to use the data request process to highlight datasets that haven't yet been catalogued on Data.gov.uk. There are quite a few such datasets, as some public authorities maintain their own data repositories for specific purposes.

I've taken a quick look at the CCG spatial data. The dataset is clipped to the coastline, which is probably why it looks "over precise" to you along the estuaries and in coastal areas. That is a standard practice for administrative boundaries in the UK; datasets are either clipped to the coastline or based on the extent of the realm. You may be more accustomed to boundary datasets that follow the extent of the realm. There's an explanation of the difference on pages 3 and 4 of this ONS document: Boundary Dataset Guidance.

-- Owen Boswarva, 06/09/2013

Edit: Just realised why the name "Peter Parslow" sounded familiar, and now suspect my comments on "clipped to the coastline" vs "extent of the realm" are coals to Newcastle ;-) Other than that though, I can't see myself why the dataset should appear "over precise" ...

-- Owen Boswarva, 08/09/2013

 Flag as offensive 

What way?

OK, so this isn't the right place to request that datasets be registered in data.gov.uk

Where should I do that?

 Flag as offensive 

Registering datasets on Data.gov.uk

Well, it's a fair question.

As I understand it, listing datasets on Data.gov.uk is primarily the responsibility of the public authority that holds the data, i.e. the "publisher".

Cabinet Office has recently prevailed upon government departments to provide inventories of all the datasets they hold, so there has been an influx of new Data.gov.uk records. However that effort to "sweep up" missing datasets did not extend to local authorities or the NHS.

For CCG Maps specifically, the best option is probably to try and persuade NHS England to add a record to the Data.gov.uk catalogue.

I've started a spreadsheet of notable datasets missing from Data.gov.uk.

-- Owen Boswarva, 20/09/2013

 Flag as offensive 

CCG Maps are now catalogued on Data.gov.uk

CCG area boundaries now have an entry on Data.gov.uk: CCG Map.

-- Owen Boswarva, 26/06/2014

 Flag as offensive