Court judgments

Status: 
Escalated to data holder
Data request description: 
Electronic copies of significant court judgments as currently provided by the Royal Courts of Justice to BAILII.
Reason: 
Other
The Royal Courts of Justice currently provide copies of significant judgments to the British and Irish Legal Information Institute (BAILII), for publication on the bailii.org website. BAILII is effectively the sole supplier providing this judgment publication service, under a contract originally agreed with the Department for Constitutional Affairs. I understand this arrangement was to be put out for tender by MOJ in 2012, but I do not know the current status of that exercise. I accept that there is a case for MOJ to maintain a supplier contract to ensure publication of significant judgments. My request is that MOJ should simultaneously release electronic copies of those judgments under the Open Government Licence, so that (a) they may be republished more widely via other websites and services and (b) they may be properly indexed by web search engines such as Google.
Suggested use: 
Business Use
Personal Use
Community Work
Research
Wider republication of significant judgments on websites and via other services.
Benefits overview: 
UK court judgments are not currently indexed in any detail by search engines such as Google, due to the limitations of the existing MOJ/BAILII arrangements. BAILII is not widely known outside the legal profession and ancillary fields of expertise. People who are not familiar with legal information cannot easily find copies of judgments. Wider circulation of court judgments under the Open Government Licence would support proper indexing and increase accessibility of case law to the general public. (Open availability of legal information is a fundamental of public transparency. Release of the judgments currently supplied to BAILII should be seen only as a first step within this broader context. Too much UK legal information, including most case law and court listings, remains subject to exclusive arrangements and/or available only via commercial services.)

Comments

"Escalated due to quality/format issue"

To be clear, the barrier here is lack of availability of court judgments outside the BAILII arrangement, and lack of open licensing for re-use of that information. This is a core open data issue, not simply an issue of quality or format.

For more background on the arguments for opening up court judgments please see, as examples, this article by Judith Townend and this Guardian editorial.

-- Owen Boswarva, 12/03/2013

 Flag as offensive