Opinions on the commercialisation of open data?

Dear all,

I am looking to find out what people's opinions are on the commercialisation of open data in the United Kingdom? The freedom of information act released in 2000 has completely changed the way the public can interact with and use data held by public bodies. Since the launch of this act there have been multiple uses of such open data; some for uses such as academic research and other for commercial profit (either directly or indirectly).

One way to demonstrate the commercial use of FOI is to do a Google news search for the phrase "freedom of information request" (with the inverted commas included) and set the search tools to show only UK results. By doing this you'll see the extent of the use of FOI requests in order to create publications for the media.

Some research companies are directly collecting as much public/government data as they can, either through open data scraping or mass FOI requests. This data is then broken down, filtered and sold to companies in chunks for profit.

I am fully behind the use of open data and giving the public transparent access to as much information as is safely possible. But I can't help think that more people are gaining commercially out of this than was originally intended. Or to put another spin on it, the commercial use of this data is more widespread than the purely academic/non-profit side of things.

What are your thoughts?

Comments

FOI = access, open data = re-use

Sorry, this is somewhat confused. "Open data" refers to data that is re-usable under an open licence. Freedom of Information only provides access to information (including data); it does not provide open rights to re-use the data. "Open data" is not simply a synonym for "publicly available data".

In other words the premise of your question is wrong; commercial re-use of open data is not driven by the FOI Act. The increasing willingness of public authorities to *also* release their data under an open data licence does encourage wider commercial re-use of public data assets of course, but that is completely intentional.

-- Owen Boswarva, 25/10/2013

 Flag as offensive 

Commercial reuse was much of the point

Owen is spot on. FOI is quite different. Rewind back to the genesis of Open Data and you'll find papers claiming large benefits to GDP from allowing commercial organisations to add value to data released by government in machine-readable form. Reuse by the public (or at least by non-commercial organisations) was also seen as beneficial in tis own right, and of course users of whatever is developed (commercially and non-commercially) can then also add value...

Another driver was greater accountability of public services to the public they serve. No problem with that, but if you look at the new releases area of the site this attempt to encourage an armchair auditor role sometimes seems to have taken over. I wonder how many of the "Spend of £25K or over by such-and-such a body" datasets have no users at all! They may contribute to greater efficiency, not something to be sneezed at, but do they have any commercial value?

The real value of Open Data, in my view, lies with larger datasets that can be linked and analysed in truly innovative fashions, whether the analysis is done within government, by business for profit, or by non-commercial organisations or individuals because they see potential for something valuable.

I suppose that if enough FOI requests are made about a dataset, it may result in the data holder deciding to go down the open data route, because it is cheaper to do that systematically rather than handle a host of specialised ad hoc requests. The answers to some FOI requests are made readily available through websites such as "What Do They Know?" by the person who asked but as Owen says commercial reuse is not permitted. I suppose there is an argument that public sector bodies should make all FOI responses very easily available to the public (but it would not generally be as machine-readable data as FOI only imposes an obligation to supply information in the form in which it already exists). Maybe some already do that.

 Flag as offensive 

Thanks for the clarification

Owen and Exstat,

Thanks very much for your detailed responses and taking the time to explain open data fully to me. I can really see the benefit of different 3rd party sources using machine readable information as they see fit to generate some interesting and beneficial uses for the data.

From what I've learned so far open data would be of great value to linked data (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linked_data) on the web, which is still in it's infancy.

Thanks for the interesting introduction to open data!

 Flag as offensive 

Privacy

In my opinion there is no such thing as privacy anymore, especially when in comes to internernet data. Commpercialisation of privat data has a massive potential, so there is no way it will be forbidden. 

 Flag as offensive