Outline

Code of Practice

6 Costs and fees

6.1

It is important to distinguish between the costs to the public authority of complying with section 1(1) for a request for a dataset, the cost of providing it in a re-usable format under section 11(1A), and the fees that can be charged to the applicant for making a dataset (where it is also a relevant copyright work) available for re-use under section 11A.

6.2

Fees Regulations for access made under sections 9, 12 and 13 of the Act apply to the right of access to datasets as to other information. The activities for which a fee may be charged (under Regulation 6) include, if such a preference is expressed by the applicant, provision of a dataset on portable media and posting the dataset on a host facility, which might be the authority’s own website or through a third party provider.

Doesn't this suggest a fee

Doesn't this suggest a fee would be chargeable for asking the authority to host it on their own website? If so, that seems odd. Perhaps it's an acknowledgement that some authorities will be charged by their IT provider? If that's the case the cost should be absorbed by the authority - the requester should not be punished because the authority failed to choose an IT provider that doesn't have an archaic business model that charges for simple website modifications. There is a greater benefit in showing up such ridiculous charging regimes by forcing the authority to suffer for agreeing to it. Tough love, you might say.

 Flag as offensive 

Disclosure Log

Some authorities already have a disclosure log up and running. Is this section suggesting that those authorities are now going to have to start charging to put information up on their websites? This seems strange seeing as we have been doing it for several years now and not taking any payment.

 Flag as offensive 

"a fee may be charged" "may

"a fee may be charged"

"may be" means it's an option, not a requirement

 Flag as offensive 
6.3

Cost of complying with the request

A request for a dataset should initially be treated in the same way as a request for any information under the Act. Under section 12(1) of the Act, a public authority is not obliged to comply with section 1(1), i.e. inform the applicant whether it holds the dataset and, if so, to communicate the dataset, if it estimates that the cost of doing so would exceed the ‘appropriate limit’ as defined in the Fees Regulations for access. The fees the public authority can charge the requester for providing the information are set out in these Regulations.

6.4

Cost of providing the dataset in a reusable format

If the cost of complying with the request would not exceed the appropriate limit and the information is not otherwise exempt, the public authority must provide the dataset (subject to any right to charge a fee). If the requestor expresses a preference for the dataset in electronic form, the public authority must provide it in a reusable format, so far as reasonably practicable. In deciding whether it would be reasonably practicable to provide the dataset in a reusable format, the public authority can take account of all the circumstances of the case, including the costs of doing so. These costs may include, for example, the cost of converting the dataset from a proprietary format to a format such as CSV. If the cost of using an external contractor is taken into account such that it is considered not reasonably practicable to provide the dataset in a re-usable format, the need to use that contractor and the cost of doing so must be justifiable. The Act does not prescribe any cost limit for determining what is reasonably practicable. The size and the resources of the public authority may be relevant here. If the public authority concludes that, in all the circumstances of the case, it would not be reasonably practicable to provide the dataset in a reusable format, then the authority must still provide the dataset in another format (again subject to the appropriate limit and/or any right to charge a fee).

License even when dataset not provided

Even when an authority judges that a dataset cannot cost effectively be provided they should still be asked to apply an appropriate license to the non-machine readable release that they provide.

This will ensure third parties are not restricted in then turning the non-machine readable product into a machine readable product following it's publication. 

 Flag as offensive 

Encouraging open data engagement

The guidance may also want to encourage authorities to actively engage with re-users in working out the appropriate format for the data, and managing the costs associated with providing machine readable data: for example, consultants may charge a much higher price for something a civic hacktivist would be willing to do for no cost; or parties requesting data may be willing to provide advice and support to the authority on extracting data in an appropriate way. The guidance may not be the only place to do this - but encouraging authorities to explore collaborative, rather than antagonistic relationships, with data requesters where possible would be good. 

 Flag as offensive 

Contractor costs

The guidance could explicitly ask agencies to, where refusing to provide a machine readable dataset on grounds of cost, to provide details of the hourly or daily rate of the contractor and anticipated time that has led to the cost exceeding the threshold. 

This is information that, if the request was under the threshold, may be published through the public spending open data requirements, or that may be FOIable independently, and so there should be no reason for this not to be explicitly included in any refusal response to a request for machine readable data. 

 Flag as offensive 

When refusing on the grounds

When refusing on the grounds of cost the costs should be stated, and there could be the option for the requester to fund either the excess above the threshold or the full cost.

 Flag as offensive 

When data is released to an individual what happens to the d

What happens to the data set when it is released to person A?  I haven't seen anything that tells you what to do next.  I would have thought that organisations should be then publicising the data on their own website, data.gov.uk etc, so that other people are aware the data set exists and is in the public domain to be used - This in my opinion would be good practice, but we all know good practice isn't always implemented.  I'm also assuming some sort of retent and disposal schedules would need to be applied to the data sets.

This can probably be ignored now as the next part of the consultation covers this comment.

 Flag as offensive 

Suggest removing the phrase "proprietary format"

I would suggest removing the phrase "proprietary format". I think it is being used here as equivalent to a format that does not support re-use. However there are some file formats that remain technically proprietary but are generally considered to support re-use, because the IP owners have undertaken not to assert rights that would limit their wide use. See for example the Microsoft Open Specification Promise, which applies to the .xls file format.

 Flag as offensive 
6.5

Fees for providing the information

Fees for providing a dataset, as for any other information, to an applicant may only be charged in accordance with sections 9 and 13 of the Act and the Fees Regulations for access.

6.6

Fees for allowing re-use of a relevant copyright work

In exceptional cases a public authority that is the owner of a copyright work in a dataset being released may exercise the power to charge a fee for re-use of that dataset.

6.7

Section 11B of the Act provides that the Secretary of State may make regulations about the fees for making relevant copyright works available for re-use; public authorities can charge a fee, in accordance with any regulations under section 11B, for making that copyright work available for re-use. Alternatively, if a public authority is entitled to charge a fee under any other legislation for the re-use of a relevant copyright work, then it may do so on that basis instead. [Note: Guidance will be provided here once the regulations have been drafted and approved]