Datasets about public rights of way.

Status: 
ODUG developing business case
Notes: 

This data request has been included in the work ODUG is undertaking on third party licences and Rights of Way. For further information, please see http://data.gov.uk/open-data-user-group-benefits-cases-for-release-of-data

Data request description: 
Many local councils have datasets containing details about their public rights of ways. Often these are ESRI shape files or MapInfo files.
Reason: 
The data is published but not in a format I can download and use (e.g. only displayed onscreen or only downloadable as a PDF rather than CVS)
Some local councils have datasets containing details about their public rights of ways. Often these are ESRI shape files or MapInfo files. I have requested that these datasets be released as Open Data (either with an Ordnance Survey OpenData Licence or an Open Government Licence). I've approached several councils. Although four have released their data, three councils have refused to do so. When later I ask them to permit access to these datasets under the Freedom of Information Act, they reply that they have released the information in paper form at the Council Offices or on the interactive map available on their web site. These are inappropriate as I've written a web application that needs access to the data itself. Some councils use the Environmental Information Regulations Act rather than the FOI Act and they have declined to release access to their dataset even though section 6 of the EIR Act says "where an applicant requests that the information be made available in a particular form or format, a public authority shall make it so available".
Suggested use: 
Community Work
I've provided a web application (http://www.rowmaps.com) that enables people to see maps showing public rights of way. Access to this web application is free of charge. Currently it knows about the public rights of way of four local councils but others will be added if councils release their datasets as Open Data.
Benefits overview: 
Sometimes a local council will provide an interactive map that show the public rights of way of that council. These interactive maps often use different interfaces. My web application has one interface that will show public rights of way for the whole country working seamlessly across council boundaries. It is currently working for the four councils that have released their datasets as Open Data. The underlying map can be from the Ordnance Survey, OpenStreetMap, Google or Bing. These are provided under licence. You can ask for a map that is close to a specific place. And once you've done that, there are details about how you could include such a map on your own web page. You can also build a route for a walk, run, etc., by selecting several rights of way and having estabished a route you can ask for it to be output in KML or GPX.

Comments

My experience

I fully support this request. Further, I have no idea why people would vote this down unless they are in some way connected to the Orndance Survey, the local authorities or some other private company that beneifts from the lack of access to this data.

I have had experience of requesting public rights of way data from an English Local Authority. As they provided an interactive map of their public rights of way on their website it was clear that they held the data in a digital form (i.e. as a GIS dataset). I therefore conatced them asking for a copy of this data to be provided with me as an ESRI shapefile. To be fair to them they were quick to respeond, however they asked that I filled out a form confirming that I agree to 9 very restrictive terms (copied below).

As these were unacceptable for my intended use of the data I asked for an internal review and whether the data could be released as Open Data. This led to many back and forth emails in which I had to explain to them that the data was likely derived by 'tracing' over Ordnance Survey's MasterMap and therefore the data would have to be released under the OS OpenData licence (rather than the Open Government Licence). I also had to explain that as a surveying authority it was highly likely that they were a member of Ordnance Survey's Public Sector Mapping Agreement (PSMA) scheme and therefore have access to an "Exemption Process" which allows them to release data derived from OS mapping products as open data.

The data was eventually released but the process was very long and there are over 150 Local Authorites.

 - - - The original restrictive terms - - -

  1. The supplied GIS data can only be used in connection with the specified use stated above.

  2. Any computer systems holding the supplied GIS data must be password protected. In addition, only authorised staff or the specified individual should have access to the supplied GIS data. All original copies, back up media copies and hard copies produced from the supplied GIS data must be kept in a secure environment.

  3. Any security breaches must be notified to a Norfolk County Council representative (contact details at the foot of this document).

  4. The supplied GIS data must not be copied, loaned or sold to any third party, except as part of the specified use.

  5. The supplied GIS data must not be used for any other activity or business that may be undertaken by the organisation supplied.

  6. Where maps, charts, plans, reports and other graphic media contain the supplied GIS data the following PROW disclaimer text must be used: "The line depicting a right of way does not define the precise route, centre or edge of the path but only indicates its location. The right of way data is provided for general information purposes only. Please consult the definitive map held by Norfolk County Council which shows the lawful line of the right of way."

  7. Where maps, charts, plans, reports and other graphic media contain the supplied GIS data the correct OS Copyright text must be displayed to reflect that the supplied GIS data is based upon OS mapping data.

  8. The supplied organisation must destroy any copies of the supplied GIS data upon completion of the work, only retaining the supplied GIS data where it is necessary to the specified use e.g. as part of official or project documentation.

  9. The supplied GIS data is essentially a snapshot of the supplied GIS data for a given time, and may not be complete or entirely accurate in terms of attribute information or geographical position. The supplied organisation must be aware that this will affect any decisions made upon the supplied GIS data. Norfolk County Council does not accept any responsibility for decisions made based upon this supplied GIS data, and are not liable. Supplied GIS data is used at the supplied organisation’s/individual’s own risk.

 Flag as offensive 

Fully Support

The nationwide release of PROW (and other path) data would be a great boon for route planning for outdoor pursuits so encouraging health giving uses of the countryside.

It would be so much easier for those of us attempting to provide such facilities to have the data available in a consistent form nationally rather than having to make do with piecemeal releases from a few forward thinking authorities with for example, different segmentation treatments. Surely the PROW data has been submitted to OS by the councils so could be re-released by them in bulk as OS OpenData.

 Flag as offensive 

Councils need educating

I think the issue here is primarily a matter of increasing awareness and understanding in councils as to the benefits of Open Data, and the provisions under the PSMA for them to release OS-derived GIS data. I have some notes to help those requesting such data at http://robert.mathmos.net/osm/prow/council-gis.html

There's a table on the OpenStreetMap wiki listing details of Public Rights of Way data available from UK councils which you may find useful in tracking down other councils who might have data to release: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/UK_local_councils

Finally, I have a related request at http://data.gov.uk/data-requests/os-opendata-license concerning potential issues with OS OpenData License that these useful GIS data-sets can be offered under as a result of the PSMA.

 Flag as offensive 

Ordnance Survey should agree a blanket PSMA exemption for PR

I recent wrote a blog post about open data release of Public Rights of Way (PRoW) mapping and information.

It seems to me that the most effective approach would be to persuade Ordnance Survey to agree a blanket application of the Public Sector Mapping Agreement exemption process, and communicate that to PSMA members. That would enable LAs to release the data under the OS OpenData Licence without each making a formal request to Ordnance Survey.

-- Owen Boswarva, 16/10/2012

 Flag as offensive 

Rights of Way, List of Streets

I agree that the public rights of way should be available in an easy to use format.

They are currently very difficult to obtain in most cases, usually being available by visiting in person to the council offices in working hours.A small percentage of councils have released data in electronic format, in various forms.

These pieces of information should be available to download in a useful format without excessively restrictive licensing now.

In the longer term, the information should be available as the up to date definitive source.

  • rights of way
  • RoW modification orders
  • RoW modification order applications 
  • list of streets
  • Traffic Regulation Orders
 Flag as offensive