Data issue with Road Safety data

Status: 
Closed
Outcome: 
Data already available
Notes: 

The "Road Safety - Blood Alcohol Content - Coroners Matched Data" available on gov.uk: http://data.gov.uk/dataset/road-accidents-safety-data incudes a row for each fatality (aged 16 or over) recorded in STATS19 for the year in question. Fatalities from STATS19 which were successfully matched to the data received from coroners and procurators fiscal have a blood alcohol value in the first column with those unsuccessfully matched given an unknown BAC value. There is a data guide available under the additional links section at the above link which includes a description of each variable in the dataset. The STATS19 'Accidents indexes' , ‘Vehicle References’ and 'Casualty References' are not included in the Coroners Matched Data files as doing so would enable users to link to the Accident, Vehicle and Casualties data files. This would enable information such as the location and date of accidents in which someone over the legal alcohol limit died to be obtained. Such information could identify and cause distress to the living persons involved in the accident. It would be possible to obtain the accident indexes, vehicle references and casualty references by signing an end user licence with the Department. However, it must be shown that the data will be used for a valid purpose e.g. research. Please email: roadacc.stats@dft.gsi.gov.uk if you are interested in setting up an end user licence.

Data request description: 
The "Road Safety - Blood Alcohol Content - Coroners Matched Data" since 2009 have been made available in the Road Safety collection, which seems to me to be a very good step for public research. But at the moment, the resulting matched data lacks a description appropriate for virtually any research use. At the moment, we cannot know from the files simple context questions such as whether the data sample all the fatalities recorded in STATS19 for that year; whether the order of the dataset is random (nominal scaling) or not... And no integrated analysis with the rest of the STATS19 datasets in the collection is possible, because the datapoint references used for matching are not provided. The straightforward solution would be to provide the 'Accidents indexes' or 'Casualty References' used for matching (whichseems to be non-disclosive in character) as available in the other datasets. Lastly, a mere suggestion: would it be possible to have it distributed by month as the Digital Breath Test data is? Thank you for your time
Suggested use: 
Research
Benefits overview: 
Would allow very possibility of analysis (currently, I would be surprised and interested if anyone could provide me with any sort of analysis made using this data as presented). Again, this is not meant as criticism as far as there is a very good rationale behind publication, so fixing this issue of the description and the choice of variables presented is crucial.

Comments

Department for Transport response

The "Road Safety - Blood Alcohol Content - Coroners Matched Data" available on gov.uk: http://data.gov.uk/dataset/road-accidents-safety-data incudes a row for each fatality (aged 16 or over) recorded in STATS19 for the year in question. Fatalities from STATS19 which were successfully matched to the data received from coroners and procurators fiscal have a blood alcohol value in the first column with those unsuccessfully matched given an unknown BAC value. There is a data guide available under the additional links section at the above link which includes a description of each variable in the dataset. The STATS19 'Accidents indexes' , ‘Vehicle References’ and 'Casualty References' are not included in the Coroners Matched Data files as doing so would enable users to link to the Accident, Vehicle and Casualties data files. This would enable information such as the location and date of accidents in which someone over the legal alcohol limit died to be obtained. Such information could identify and cause distress to the living persons involved in the accident. It would be possible to obtain the accident indexes, vehicle references and casualty references by signing an end user licence with the Department. However, it must be shown that the data will be used for a valid purpose e.g. research. Please email: roadacc.stats@dft.gsi.gov.uk if you are interested in setting up an end user licence.

 Flag as offensive