Outline

Code of Practice

8 Advice and assistance to persons making or intending to make requests for datasets

8.1

Public authorities are required to provide advice and assistance to people who have made, or who propose to make, requests for datasets just as they would for any other information. This is under section 16 of the Act (a public authority’s duty to provide advice and assistance to applicants and potential applicants).

8.2

As with FOI requests for any information, applicants should provide a sufficient description of the dataset sought for the public authority to be able to identify and locate it. Public authorities should provide assistance to the applicant that will help him or her describe it more clearly. This assistance could be in the form of published inventories of datasets held by the public authority, with details of their availability, and also provision of ad hoc help.

Derivable datasets

If an applicant requests a dataset which doesn't exist as such, but could be derived from datasets which are available, how much help is the authority required to give? Should they:

  1. deny the request because the dataset requested doesn't exist
  2. say that dataset doesn't exist but suggest other existing datasets which might be relevant
  3. identify specifically which existing datasets could be used to derive the one requested
  4. explain how to derive the one requested from the existing datasets
  5. derive the requested dataset and provide it to the applicant?
 Flag as offensive 
8.3

Where specialist software is required to access and/or re-use certain datasets, authorities should advise applicants where they can obtain such software. However, care should be taken not to unnecessarily endorse any particular manufacturer’s product.

More open formats should be preferred

A need for specialist software may be unavoidable in a few cases, but shouldn't the guidance recommend avoiding it wherever possible? Usually it will be possible to extract the data into a non-proprietary format, and this is more open. Also, advising people where to find software that can read a particular specialist format, without unnecessarily endorsing a particular product, might require a knowledge of the software market that authorities won't always have.

 Flag as offensive 
8.4

Public authorities should make it clear if any copyright or database rights in a dataset are owned by a third party and, if so, the identity of that third party. This will alert potential re-users of the limitation on re-use and the need to contact the rights owner to seek permission to re-use the dataset.