Outline

Code of Practice

5 Giving permission for datasets to be re-used

5.1

Datasets must be released with accompanying details of any licence conditions that apply to re-use of the dataset or otherwise any limitation on re-use by virtue of third party intellectual property rights.

5.2

The public authority should ascertain whether copyright and/or database rights in the dataset are owned solely by the authority, that there is no other copyright owner with rights in the dataset. Nothing in the Act removes any rights of third parties in that dataset. If a public authority grants a licence to re-use a dataset where it is subject to intellectual property owned by a third party, the grant may constitute an infringement of the third party’s rights. Consideration should also be given to the extent to which it is appropriate to disclose such information, in particular with reference to sections 41 and 43(2) of the Act.

Third Party Intellectual Property Rights

The references to third party intellectual property rights are difficult to reconcile with section 11A(1)(c) of the FOIA 2000, which excludes from the ambit of section 11A datasets other than those where the public authority is the only owner of the copyright. The scope of this Code consequently risks exceeding its statutory basis, addressing more than just the application of section 11A.

 Flag as offensive 
5.3

Where the copyright or database right in a dataset is owned wholly or partly by a third party, a public authority can only give permission for re-use of the dataset if it has been authorised to do so by the relevant third party rights holder. The ‘re-use duty’ only applies where the public authority is the only owner of the copyright or database right. If the authority does not have the legal authority to make it available for re-use it should make it clear to the applicant when releasing the dataset that this is the case. Even when the public authority is not able to license re-use, it must still provide the dataset in a re-usable format, so far as reasonably practicable, if the applicant has asked for an electronic version.

"if the applicant has asked

"if the applicant has asked for an electronic version." should be removed, IMO

 Flag as offensive 

Plans, Drawings and Maps

Notwithstanding our general comments below relating to extent that this Code should be addressing datasets that fall outside the scope of section 11A, it is worth mentioning that where the dataset comprises plans, drawings or maps, the public authority is mandated to use a particular formula of wording in order to indicate that a third party enjoys reserved rights in the data. Details can be found in the the Copyright (Material Open to Public Inspection) (Marking of Copies of Plans and Drawings) Order 1990 and The Copyright (Material Open to Public Inspection) (Marking of Copies of Maps) Order 1989.

 Flag as offensive 

Unreusable Data in a Reusable Format

We would recommend adding some explanatory text to the following sentence, lest it be misinterpreted as meaning that the public authority must positively facilitate the unauthorised use of third party intellectual property!  (The purpose of this provision is, of course, to facilitate the re-use of the information once the required third party permission has been obtained).

Even when the public authority is not able to license re-use, it must still provide the dataset in a re-usable format... 

This leads us on to a more serious point: the Code might well put a duty on public authorities to supply datasets in electronic format: however the user will not necesarily be able to lawfully view the data in that electronic file (let alone put the data to use) if it contains third party material. This is because, by viewing data that has been recorded in electronic format, the information is temporarily stored in the memory of the user's computer, which is an act restricted by copyright.

 Flag as offensive 
5.4

Authorities should consider how best to streamline the process of ascertaining the ownership of copyright and database rights in the dataset, and where relevant obtaining authority to license the dataset, ideally before any requests arrive. Identification and acknowledgement of third party rights is good practice and may prevent unnecessary applications and delay in responding to requests.

Obtaining Authority

Beyond our general comments (see below) relating to extent that this Code should be addressing datasets that fall outside the scope of section 11A, we are concerned about the wording of paragraph 4. The provisions relating to "obtaining authority" could be read as meaning that public authorities should have a process in place for obtaining authority to license a dataset if so requested. To do so goes far beyond any obligation hitherto placed on public authorities, and risks being extremely burdensome. Ordinarily, the extent to which an authority has the power to permit the re-use of third party information will have been agreed contractually when the dataset was first commissioned: re-users cannot expect public authorities to go back to the data owners in order to renegotiate such agreements.

 Flag as offensive 
5.5

Licensing

If the dataset that is being provided, or any part of it, is a relevant copyright work, the public authority must make that work available for re-use in accordance with the terms of one of the specified licences in this Code. Authorities are encouraged to use the UK Open Government Licence as most datasets can be re-used without a charge. It is envisaged that the other licences will only be used in exceptional circumstances.

Crown-Owned Works

We believe that this section of the Code should be clearer in explaining that the provisions relating to reuse and charging do not apply to Crown-owned copyright works or Crown-owned database rights, per section 11A(8) FOIA 2000.

 Flag as offensive 

Custom Licences

This wording "the public authority must make that work available for re-use in accordance with the terms of one of the specified licences in this Code" could be unduely onerous on public authorities who hitherto have enjoyed a wider freedom to draft terms and conditions tailored to the nature of the data that they are licensing. For example, when licensing a dataset, the public authority would generally want a custom set of indemnity and limitation clauses included in the licence contract in order to precisely define the extent of its responsibilities and liabilities should there be a problem with the data.

 Flag as offensive 

Resources to provide information

In providing an open government license the Council will not be benefit financially from providing the information. It is recommended that the licence provided is one which the Council will benefit from providing the information. 

Further, the additional requirements proposed in the code will place a greater burden on the Council’s resources to make information available at a time when the Council is facing further significant cuts to its budget. The recently announced Local Government Finance Settlement will see the Council’s budget reduce by approximately £37 million over the next 3 years and this is on top of significant cuts already made to Council funding over the previous 3 financial years.

 Flag as offensive 
5.6

UK Open Government Licence: The Open Government Licence is the main licensing model for the UK Government. Established under the UK Government Licensing Framework, the model encourages the use and re-use of a wide range of public sector information. The Open Government Licence is a non-transactional open licence which enables use and re-use with virtually no restrictions. It permits use and re-use, including for commercial purposes, at no cost to the user/re-user. The Licence can be easily used by public authorities, for example, it only requires public authorities to link to the Open Government Licence which is hosted on The National Archives website.

5.7

Non- Commercial Government Licence: It is recognised, however, that the Open Government Licence will not be appropriate in all cases, for example, in circumstances where information may only be used for non-commercial purposes. The Non-Commercial Government Licence was developed to meet those situations. As with the Open Government Licence, public authorities can link to the Non-Commercial Government Licence on The National Archives website.

5.8

Charged Licence (Beta): If re-use for commercial purposes which involves payment of a fee and/or royalties by the re-user is required, a transactional licence may be used. The licence uses standard licensing terms and forms part of the UK Government Licensing Framework and is available on the National Archives website. [Note: The Charged Licence is currently in ‘beta’ form and the National Archives is open to receiving feedback about the licence. Specific comments on this beta licence should be made through the National Archives website although this draft Code of Practice consultation welcomes general feedback on use of this licence in the final code.]