Release format

Dear Cabinet Office,

I though the whole purpose of Open Data, and this site, was to encourage the release of data in a machine readable format, i.e. CSV or some other open standard. That being the case why is more and more data being published in shape files such as GEMINI2 and INSPIRE, these are not open standards! 

I assume local authorities and the Cabinet Office both know this isn't in keeping with the intent of Open Data being accessable to all.

If local authorites are going to publish 'snapshots' of data in unusable formats at least have the common decency not to list them on a site which is meant to champion Open Data.

Thank you.

Comments

interesting

INSPIRE actually promotes data being in OGC standards - WFS and WMS, which you'd probably regard as open, but not easy to work with unless you're a GIS pro and can use the particular tools.

Of the INSPIRE / GEMINI2 / UK Location datasets, only 243 out of 10299 mention shapefiles, so it's hardly a flood. And I believe you could argue there are plenty more tools compatible with Shapefiles than with open standards.

I'm no expert in these formats though - what would you suggest? Do KML or GeoJSON cut the mustard compared to Shapefiles in terms of comparable features, tool support, openness?

And it would be interesting to know what part of openness / accessibility you and others are interested in - this is needed to build a case to get things changed.

 Flag as offensive