“@YesScotland: Scotland more than pays its way #VoteYes #bigbigdebate pic.twitter.com/ah8Zymp6GC” hooyada waas, have you're own country nacala
-
-
@YesScotland@Bryce9A 9.5 % of tax = £53bn 9.3% of spend-£63bn . So thanx Sctland gets £10bn more than raises Cheers#BetterTogether -
@54Beats44 Budget deficit is UK wide. Not the point. Point is Scotland doesn't get given a greater % than it contributes. -
@Bryce9A But spending per head is higher in Scot than rUK. -
.
@YesScotland Total Scottish public sector revenue 9.1% of UK total, compared to 9.3% of total UK public sector expenditure.#indyref -
@54Beats44 Correct, but Scotland raises more tax per head than rUK. That's what that graphic I posted proved. -
@Bryce9A 15% of that is oil which is forecast to decline & cease GDP gap analysis is frightening if you think in that way How do u replace? -
@Bryce9A But if you spend in actual £s more than you raise in £s that is a problem -NOT % that counts. -
@YesScotland@Tuigen without currency sovereignty, Scotland will struggle in the future. You need your own currency. -
@Tat_Loo Having control over money supply would help, yes, but multiple EU countries don't anyway (such as Greece, admittedly)@YesScotland -
@54Beats44 Yes a budget deficit is bad, but its UK wide. Not relevant to the 'does Scotland get more than its fair share" question. -
@Tuigen pretty much my point. No control over your FX rate, your interest rates or the currency you borrow in = trouble@YesScotland -
@Bryce9A In simple accounting terms P&L. If you spend £19 & get £5 income u are in deficit.Costs are costs You dont exclude cost of finance -
Yeah, let's secede over a mere 0.2% disparity, that's reasonable.
@YesScotland -
“
@YesScotland: Scotland more than pays its way#VoteYes#bigbigdebate pic.twitter.com/Q7Lb5QHl2R” YES! -
@54Beats44@Bryce9A When oil tax receipts start to dip/disappear do u think we'll still get more per head than rUK?? -
@Dotsy1978@Bryce9A Uk is bigger that is the a fact therefore risk sharing is dispersed like economies of scale. -
@Bryce9A Ouch! Think@54Beats44 got you there! -
@PeteGunstone That's your misunderstanding. The figures that Scotland contributes more than it receives were not refuted.@54Beats44
Yes Scotland
Ed Miliband
54 Beats 44
Billy Austin
Hazel MacIver
Tat Loo
Greyscale Spectrum
Kyle Alexander
brady
Scott
pete gunstone